A few thoughts on a common argument used by those in the pro-choice position
I recently read a few statements made by Rudy Guilliani who wished to re-iterate his views on abortion. He said that while he believed it was wrong, he still believed it should be legal. My first thought was, "How can you believe something is wrong and still believe it should be legal?" I discussed this with my dad and he made an excellent point. He basically said that there are cases where you can believe something is wrong, but you can't really make a law against it. He gave the example of lying. Yes, I believe lying is wrong, but it would be hard to make a law against it. I replied, "Well, I guess part of it comes down to how serious the issue is." Following this train of thought (the seriousness of the issue), I was reminded of an incident that was given by Scott Klusendorf, a man who travels around the country teaching others how to debate the pro-life position. He was at the park with his son when he got into a friendly conversation with a mom. She asked what he did for a living and after he finished with his job description she said, "You know, I believe abortion is wrong, but I still believe it should be legal." Scott then asked her, "So, why do you believe abortion is wrong?" She was silent for a minute and then said, "Wow, no one has ever asked me that before." I highly doubt she would have responded that way had someone asked, "So, why do you believe lying or shoplifting is wrong?" Again-when forced to think about why abortion is wrong, one realizes this is very serious topic. To be honest, I can't recall how the rest of their conversation went, but I realized that we so often never ask people why they believe something is wrong. The next time someone makes that oh-so-common pro-choice argument, I'm going to do what Mr. Klusendorf did-force the person to think about why he or she believes it's wrong. My hope and prayer is that people will be forced to think about their stance on abortion and ultimately come to the conclusion that it's wrong because the unborn are human.
2 comments:
Good post. And the question, "Why do you think it's wrong" is a kind of non-threatening way to get into the discussion since it stems from their own position.
Hi Rachel!
Just thought I'd stop in and say hello, and then discovered that I hadn't read this post of yours before. It's a good one... I'll have to try that question sometime.
I used to get into some great discussions about abortion with my fellow students & professor when I was an art student, working on a piece about abortion. I think I made them think a bit.... hopefully I did, anyway!
I just wrote a few new posts about our move to Arizona, and I mentioned you in one of them. :) I hope you are hanging in there with Jim being gone so much this summer!
I think of you & miss you lots. Hmmm... seems like it would be almost time for Marissa's violin lesson right about now if we were there!
Talk to you later...
your friend,
Amy :)
Post a Comment